Written by Tyson Ray | CFP®, CEPA®, CIMA® | Founding Partner, CEO, Senior Wealth Advisor
Interest rate announcements can make it sound as though one institution chooses what borrowing and saving should cost. Tyson explains how buyers, sellers, borrowers, and lenders also help determine where rates ultimately land.
When interest rates move, the Federal Reserve usually gets the credit or the blame. That can make it sound as though a small group of people meet in Washington, choose a number, and determine what every bank, borrower, and investor will pay or earn. The Fed plays an important role, but that is not the whole story.
Interest rates are also prices. Like the price of a house, they are influenced by supply, demand, and what buyers and sellers are willing to accept. Understanding that can help make the constant discussion about rising and falling rates feel a little less mysterious.
An interest rate becomes more useful when we understand what it is being compared with.
- Compared with inflation, does the rate offer the potential to preserve purchasing power?
- Compared with another bond, does it involve more time or more credit risk?
- Compared with keeping money readily available, what are you giving up by committing it for a particular period?
- Compared with other investments, what role is the bond or fixed-income investment intended to play?
This is the part of the interest-rate conversation that matters to your financial plan.
Debt has buyers and sellers
Most people understand how supply and demand affect the price of a house. The seller wants the highest possible price. The buyer would prefer to pay less. If several people want the same house, the seller may be able to command a higher price. If buyers are scarce, the seller may need to lower the price to complete a transaction.
Debt has a market, too. When a government or company issues a bond, it is borrowing money. When you purchase that bond, you are lending money. The interest paid helps compensate you for allowing someone else to use your money, waiting to receive it back, and accepting the risks involved.
The borrower would prefer to pay less. The investor would prefer to earn more. The interest rate (or yield) helps bring the two sides together. Similar forces affect many of the rates we encounter, even though the markets and risks behind a Treasury bond, corporate bond, mortgage, and certificate of deposit are not identical.
Why bond prices and yields move in opposite directions
This is where the interest-rate conversation can become confusing. Suppose you own a bond paying 3 percent. Later, newly issued bonds with similar terms begin paying 4 percent. A new investor would have little reason to pay full price for your 3 percent bond when a 4 percent option is available.
To make your bond more competitive, its market price would generally need to fall. The lower purchase price raises the effective yield available to its next owner. The reverse is also true. If newly issued bonds pay less than your existing bond, investors may be willing to pay more for the income yours provides.
That is why bond prices and market interest rates generally move in opposite directions. When rates rise, the market value of existing fixed-rate bonds typically falls. When rates decline, their market value may rise. It is a relationship many people do not see because financial headlines tend to focus on the direction of rates without explaining the market happening underneath them.
What does the Federal Reserve control?
The Federal Reserve influences interest rates, but it does not directly set every rate throughout the economy. The Federal Open Market Committee establishes a target range for the federal funds rate. This is the rate banks charge one another for certain overnight loans.
Changes to that target can work their way through the financial system. They can influence other short-term rates, borrowing decisions, economic activity, employment, and inflation. However, the Fed does not simply announce what every mortgage, CD, Treasury bond, or corporate bond must pay.
Those rates are also affected by inflation expectations, the economy, the supply of available debt, the length of the loan, and the risk that the borrower may not repay it. The Fed is an important participant in the interest-rate story, but not the only participant.
Higher rates don’t have only one meaning
When rates rise, the news often sounds negative. Higher rates can be connected to inflation concerns or an effort by the Fed to slow an overheated economy. But they can also reflect strong demand for capital, greater competition from other investments, or less investor demand for assets perceived as safer.
If investors are especially concerned about the economy or markets, they may be willing to accept a lower yield in exchange for perceived safety. That increased demand can push bond prices higher and yields lower.
In other periods, investors may see more opportunities elsewhere. Bond issuers may then need to offer a higher return to attract their money. Falling rates don’t always mean conditions are improving, just as rising rates do not always mean conditions are deteriorating. The movement needs context.
Market explanations are often tidier than markets
At the end of a trading day, commentators may offer a clear explanation for why rates or markets moved.
Inflation. Employment. Consumer spending. Government borrowing. Comments from the Fed.
Those factors can certainly influence investor decisions. But markets include millions of participants with different goals, timelines, expectations, and reasons for acting.
A rate movement is the result of all those decisions coming together. No single explanation tells the entire story. That does not make economic news irrelevant. It means we should be careful about treating one day’s explanation as a complete picture or as a prediction of what will happen next.
Interest Rates – Compared to what?
We should consider more than simply whether interest rates moved up or down, but what the available choices offer in exchange for their risks and limitations. The goal is not for you to become a bond trader or interpret every Federal Reserve announcement. That is part of what you rely on us to monitor and evaluate.
But understanding that interest rates are market prices and not simple judgments about whether conditions are good or bad can make it easier to keep the latest headline in perspective. The Fed helps influence interest rates. Markets help determine them. Borrowers and lenders respond to them. And before deciding what any particular rate means, we should still ask: Compared to what?